2025 Q2 2025 Health Insurance Payer-Provider Dispute Update
Fewer Disputes Between Payers and Providers Continue in Q2 Amidst Shifting Healthcare Priorities
In the second quarter of 2025, the Trump administration introduced sweeping reforms to the healthcare sector, highlighted by the launch of its ‘Make America Healthy Again’ (MAHA) agenda.[1] These initiatives — including a major restructuring of the Department of Health and Human Services and new policy directives targeting utilization management, Medicare Advantage, and drug pricing — had wide-ranging impacts on healthcare organizations and stakeholders nationwide.[2]
Most notably, payers and providers spent the quarter anticipating the significant cuts to Medicaid, Medicare, and ACA Marketplace plans proposed in Congress’s reconciliation package that was strongly aligned with the Trump administration’s policy agenda.[3] As lawmakers debated the fiscal impact of these cuts and the potential fallout, such as an increase in rates of uninsured individuals, payers and providers continued to fight their own battles, renegotiating contracts amidst regulatory and legislative uncertainty.
For over three years, FTI Consulting’s Healthcare Strategic Communications team has closely tracked and monitored these disputes between payers and providers through public news coverage and both paid and earned media. These disputes have become increasingly complex, with both sides struggling to reach agreements on key contract terms, such as reimbursement rates, utilization management, care coordination and disease management, and performance-based quality improvement metrics. Historically, these disputes have drawn attention from third-party stakeholder players, including state and federal lawmakers, regulators and local government officials, while also generating a growing level of interest and attention from traditional and social media outlets and the general public.
What we found: Much like the first quarter of 2025, Q2 saw fewer disputes reported in traditional media outlets compared to the latter half of 2024.
Q2 2025 Healthcare Quarter in Review
- In Q2 2025, there were a total of 29 disputes reported in traditional media outlets, five of which were left unresolved.
- 51% (15 out of 29) of total disputes involved Medicare Advantage (MA) plans. Three of these disputes exclusively involved MA plans, all of which were left unresolved by the end of the second quarter of 2025.
OON = Out of Network
Healthcare reporting continues to be largely driven by fast-paced developments at the federal level, with media coverage during most of the second quarter focused on the One Big Beautiful Bill, which was passed by Congress and signed by the President on July 4, 2025. The law, which includes broad reforms across Medicaid, Medicare, and the ACA, solidified the Trump Administration’s plans to transform the national healthcare landscape. However, analyses suggest it could significantly increase uninsured rates. According to the Congressional Budget Office, changes such as the introduction of Medicaid work requirements, more frequent eligibility redeterminations, and the end of continuous coverage protections could put up to 16.9 million individuals at risk of losing health coverage.
Spotlight on Rural Healthcare: Trouble Ahead
The One Big Beautiful Bill is anticipated to place significant pressure on rural providers and payers. While there is no clear trend in disputes between rural and urban geographies to date, the pressures exerted by the law on rural healthcare may force rural payers and providers to enter negotiations over reimbursement rates more frequently.
Key provisions in the bill would reduce Medicaid spending on rural hospitals by an estimated $50.4 billion over the next decade. [4] For facilities already operating with tight margins, this could significantly weaken their leverage with payers during rate negotiations. Failed reimbursement negotiations, coupled with other mounting financial concerns for hospitals and health systems, could force rural hospitals to close or cut back essential services such as obstetrics, mental health, and emergency care. [5]
Payers are expected to face significant coverage losses and operational disruptions in the coming years, with far-reaching impacts on healthcare providers and insured individuals, particularly those in rural communities.[6] As federal policy changes take effect, contract negotiations are expected to become increasingly complex and more contentious. Payers will continue to pursue greater efficiency using utilization management tools and deepen investments in quality improvement programs to improve patient outcomes – increasing providers’ clinical and administrative requirements. These increased pressures in a rapidly tightening marketplace marked by rising rates of uninsured individuals and uncompensated care are likely to further strain relationships and contract negotiations.
Research Methodology: FTI Consulting searched multiple news databases for articles regarding negotiations over reimbursement rates between provider organizations and insurance companies. Those negotiations, which were publicly reported by a news outlet on July 1 or later, were counted for the quarter in which they were publicly reported. Negotiations that were resolved or failed to reach an agreement in one quarter but were first reported in another quarter were counted for the quarter in which they became public. Where providers no longer accept any Medicare Advantage plans, FTI Consulting has counted that decision as a single dispute.
Akshara Karthik, a summer 2025 intern for the Strategic Communications segment in the Healthcare & Life Sciences practice, contributed to this article.
Related Practices
[1] “HHS Announces Transformation to Make America Healthy Again,” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (March 27, 2025), https://www.hhs.gov/press-room/hhs-restructuring-doge.html
[2] Ibid.
[3] Tricia Neuman, Alice Burns, Juston Lo, Matthew Rae, “What Could the Health-Related Provisions in the Reconciliation Bill Mean for Older Adults?” (KFF June 26, 2025), https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/what-could-the-health-related-provisions-in-the-reconciliation-bill-mean-for-older-adults/
[4] “Rural Hospitals at Risk: Cuts to Medicaid Would Further Threaten Access,” American Hospital Association (June 13, 2025), https://www.aha.org/fact-sheets/2025-06-13-rural-hospitals-risk-cuts-medicaid-would-further-threaten-access.
[5] Jazmin Orozco Rodriguez, “‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ Would Batter Rural Hospital Finances, Researchers Say,” KFF Health News (June 12, 2025), https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/rural-hospitals-battered-by-big-beautiful-bill-researchers/
[6] Rebecca Pitt, Michael Adeyanju, Mickeala Carter, Jennifer Wall, Brian Doheny, Bella Liebler, “Losing a Lifeline: Medicaid Cuts Would Devastate Rural Hospitals and Communities,” FTI Consulting | Strategic Communications (June 18, 2025), https://fticommunications.com/losing-a-lifeline-medicaid-cuts-would-devastate-rural-hospitals-and-communities/
The views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and not necessarily the views of FTI Consulting, Inc., its management, its subsidiaries, its affiliates, or its other professionals.
FTI Consulting, Inc., including its subsidiaries and affiliates, is a consulting firm and is not a certified public accounting firm or a law firm.
FTI Consulting is an independent global business advisory firm dedicated to helping organizations manage change, mitigate risk and resolve disputes: financial, legal, operational, political and regulatory, reputational and transactional. FTI Consulting professionals, located in all major business centers throughout the world, work closely with clients to anticipate, illuminate and overcome complex business challenges and opportunities. ©2025 FTI Consulting, Inc.
All rights reserved. fticonsulting.com
