Public & Government Affairs

Irish Local and European Election Overview & Political Outlook

With counts complete and all seats now filled, the final picture of the Irish local and European elections has emerged. Current Irish Government coalition members – Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael – have been seen as the winners, performing stronger than expected and holding off the rise of Sinn Féin, who failed to meet their own pre-election expectations.[1] The results have fuelled speculation that the Government may look to call an early general election, with rumours now rife that Ireland will go to the polls in either September or October. Below, we provide an overview of the local and European election results, the key takeaways, and a look ahead at what is on the Irish political agenda over the next number of months.  

Local Election Results

At a local level, in what was somewhat of a surprising outcome to the parties themselves, the results demonstrate a notable performance from Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. The largest local party remains Fianna Fáil securing 248 seats (down from 279), Fine Gael following closely behind with 245 seats (down from 255). Unlike its coalition partners, support for the Green Party fell dramatically securing just 26 council seats, down from 44 in 2019.

Meanwhile, Sinn Féin, who up until recently had been performing strongly in the polls, may no longer be seen as the frontrunner to lead the next government after their poorer than expected performance. The party performed well below expectations with Party Leader Mary Lou McDonald calling it a disappointing outcome.[2] However, the party secured 102 seats and are the third largest party in local government, finishing with more councillors than in 2019. One councillor said that the poorer-than-expected local election campaign was due to a failure by the party to provide serious opposition to the Government in the last 12 months.[3]

Elsewhere, it was a positive week for independent candidates, as they secured more than a quarter of first preference votes, and saw 186 seats confirmed. Some commentators, including some newly elected Sinn Féin councillors remarked that Sinn Féin had lost some of the “protest vote” to independents. In terms of the smaller parties, many have retained their seats across county and city councils, with significant gains for the Social Democrats, securing 35 seats up from 19 in 2019.  Social Democrats leader, Holly Cairns, reflected on a really positive result for the party, only founded in 2015.[4]  The Labour Party has largely maintained their position securing 56 seats, down one from 2019. People Before Profit were slightly down on its 2019 polling, with 13 seats and Aontú  securing 8 seats overall.

While not the far-right wave that was expected, the outcome of the local elections demonstrated a shift for Irish politics, with five far-right candidates elected to local councils. This marks the first-time that members from registered far-right parties, such as the Irish Freedom Party and the National Party, have won seats at an election.

European Election Results

In the Dublin constituency, all four seats were filled on the 19th count on 11 June. Fine Gael’s (EPP) Regina Doherty, Fianna Fáil’s (RE) Barry Andrews, Sinn Féin’s (The Left) Lynn Boylan, and The Labour Party’s (S&D) Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, were successfully elected. Outgoing MEPs the Green Party’s (Greens) Ciarán Cuffe and Independents 4 Change’s (The Left) Clare Daly both lost their seats. The election of O’Doherty means Fine Gael retains the seat held by outgoing MEP Frances Fitzgerald who did not contest the election. Meanwhile Boylan won back the seat she lost in the 2019 European election.

In Midlands North West constituency, counting finished a week after voting took place on 14 June. Sinn Féin’s (The Left) Chris MacManus failed to retain the Sinn Féin’s seat he took over when MEP Matt Carthy was elected to the national parliament in 2020, while his constituency running mate Michelle Gildernew was also unsuccessful in her bid. Independent MEP (The Left) Luke Ming Flanagan topped the poll and was the first to be elected in the constituency. Fine Gael (EPP) had double success with Maria Walsh retaining her seat and running mate Nina Carberry was also elected, retaining the party’s seat won by Mairead McGuinness in 2019. Fianna Fáil’s (RE) Barry Cowen won the party’s first seat in the constituency since boundary changes in 2014. The final seat was won by Independent Ireland’s (no affiliation yet) Ciaran Mullooly, who becomes the recently established party’s first MEP.

In Ireland South, counting finished late on 13 June. Fine Gael’s (EPP) Seán Kelly and Fianna Fáil’s (RE) Billy Kelleher were both re-elected for another term. However, the Green Party’s (Greens) Grace O’Sullivan and Independents 4 Change’s (The Left) Mick Wallace failed to get re-elected. Current members of parliament, Sinn Féin’s (The Left) Kathleen Funchion and Independent (no affiliation yet) Michael McNamara were both elected. Fianna Fáil’s (RE) Cynthia Ní Mhurchú took the final seat in the constituency, winning a second seat for the party there. 

While many political commentators have signalled this may be a sign of things to come in the upcoming general election, given voter turnout, this is difficult to predict at this stage. The turnout in the European elections was 50.6%, while for the local elections it was 49.4%.

Key Takeaways

The elections were seen by many as a bellwether for the future general election and the results have certainly reset the political backdrop ahead of the summer. We have outlined below a number of key takeaways. 

Sinn Féin’s Poor Performance: The story that has dominated the political airwaves in the aftermath of the election has been the poor performance of Sinn Féin. While the party performed better than in the 2019 local elections, results show a collapse in support for the party, receiving just 10.7% in local elections and 14.3% in the European elections.[5]  This performance follows on from a steady decline in opinion polls in the months building up to these elections, with the results showing the drop was a real trend. With a general election likely to be called before the end of the year, it will be interesting to see how Sinn Féin attempts to halt and reverse this slide. They will likely take solace in the fact that they performed poorly in the 2019 local and European elections, but then eight months later had their strongest electoral performance in modern history in the 2020 General Election. While a usually higher voter turnout at general elections will give them hope, Sinn Féin will also likely return to focusing on core issues facing the electorate, principally housing and cost of living.

Increase in support for Independents: Sinn Féin’s poor performance left an opening for other parties and candidates to make gains. While Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil have performed better than expected, it is the growth in support for independent candidates who have polled at 19.5% and 14% local and European elections respectively.[5] If they were a singular party, then they would be one of the largest parties in the country. It is also worth noting that, the rise in support does not equate to a rise in right wing politics in Ireland, with the candidates elected spanning from the far-left to the far-right. independents have played key roles in forming previous governments in Ireland, going so far as securing senior ministerial positions in return for their support. If independent candidates also receive such large support in the next general election, it will be interesting to see if any find themselves in a similar position.

Smaller parties hold their own: There was concern ahead of these elections that the smaller political parties – particularly the Green Party, The Labour Party and Social Democrats – would perform poorly. However, similar to Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, they have outperformed their expectations, holding their ground and in some constituencies improving their support. The Social Democrats, a party only founded in 2015, in particular will be pleased as they have almost doubled their seats since the 2019 local elections. This, coupled with the performance of independents, is a significant development as the next Irish Government will likely need support of smaller parties or independents – either as a coalition member or through a confidence and supply arrangement – to be formed. It has been suggested in recent months that The Labour Party and Social Democrats – both centre left parties – should consider a merger and based on final vote results, they would have similar sized support to Sinn Féin. For now, both parties have ruled out such a move.[6]

Rise of far right fails to materialise: Ahead of these elections, there was much debate regarding the rise of the far right in Ireland, particularly on the back of an increase in anti-immigration protests and sentiment across Ireland. However, it is clear from the voting results – particularly at local level – that there was no big surge in support for the far right5. While there were independent candidates who campaigned on an immigration-sceptic message, Fine Gael, and Fianna Fáil’s pivot to a harder stance on the issue meant that the overall voting preference did not drift too far from the centre. However, the far-right made some minor gains, with The National Party’s Patrick Quinlan successfully elected to Fingal County Council, becoming the party’s first elected representative. Despite this, Ireland would appear to be an outlier in Europe, where there has been a clearer swing to the right most noticeably in Germany and France.

Looking Ahead – Impact on Irish Political Outlook

European Groupings: Ahead of the European Parliament’s first meeting next month, Ireland’s 14 MEPs will have to decide on their European political groupings. While the affiliations of the larger parties are well established (Fine Gael with the European People’s Party, Fianna Fáil with Renew Europe, Sinn Féin with The Left, and The Labour Party with Socialists and Democrats) and returning Independent Luke ‘Ming’ Flanagan remaining in The Left grouping, all eyes will be on the first time MEPs. Independent Ireland’s Ciaran Mullooly said the party is speaking to a number of political groupings and while they have yet to select which party he will join, they have ruled out ECR. Independent Michael McNamara, a former Labour Party TD, has yet to reveal which group he is considering.

EU Commissioner: The Government will now turn attention to Ireland’s candidate for EU Commissioner in the coming weeks. Fine Gael’s Mairead McGuinness is not expected to be re-nominated due to the unwritten government agreement that it is a matter for Fianna Fáil to decide. Party leader Micheál Martin has said he will be making his own decision, but will consult with his party colleagues. The party has kept its cards close to its chest on potential candidates, however Finance Minister and Martin’s constituency colleague, Michael McGrath, is thought to be a front runner. There has also been speculation that Martin will put himself forward for the position and, although he has publicly stated he is not interested, he can’t be ruled out. When asked if he would put forward both male and female candidates if requested to do so by Ursula von der Leyen (as she did previously in 2019), he  said: “We can, although part of me would say that the fundamental rules in terms of national decision-making should not be unduly undermined. That would be a traditionalist view of mine – it’s a decision for each member state. We did do it on the last occasion although it was done in a way that the outcome still became fairly, you know . . . so I think we need to be clear in demarcation lines as to the responsibilities. In this instance it’s the responsibilities of the national governments.”[7]

By–elections: Four current members of Ireland’s national parliament were elected as MEPs (Aodhán Ó Ríordáin, Barry Cowen, Michael McNamara and Kathleen Funchion), triggering a need for by-elections in four separate constituencies in the coming months. A fifth may also be required if Michael McGrath becomes the nominee for Commissioner. By-elections must take place within six months of a seat being vacated. With the successful candidates not expected to officially resign their seats until they take up their MEP seat when the parliament meets for the first time in July, this means by-elections must take place by January. Senate by-elections will also be required as current Senators Regina Doherty and Lynn Boylan were also elected to the EU Parliament.

General Election: The timing will be a headache for government parties and Taoiseach Simon Harris, who is facing pressure to call an early general election later this year following their parties combined success in both elections. While Taoiseach Harris and his coalition party colleagues have spent recent days insisting the Government will see out the rest of its term bringing us to March next year, the by-elections will be another factor which will impact the decision-making around timing. If an early election is on the table, it is expected that the Government will at least wait until it delivers Budget 2025 in September/early October before dissolving the Dáil and going to voters once again.

Related Expertise

[1] “Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil lead Irish elections”, BBC News (11 June 2024) https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cyxx9rrwgzvo

[2] Maeve McTaggart, “‘It hasn’t been our day,’ says Mary Lou McDonald amid disappointing results for Sinn Féin”, Irish Independent (9 June 2024) https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/elections-2024/european-election/it-hasnt-been-our-day-says-mary-lou-mcdonald-amid-disappointing-results-for-sinn-fein/a1130053509.html

[3] “A Sinn Féin councillor said the poorer-than-expected local election campaign was due to a failure by the party to provide serious opposition to the Government in the last 12 months”. RTE (12 June 2024) https://www.rte.ie/news/post/104456781/

[4] “Cairns hails impressive local election results for Soc Dems”, Social Democrats (10 June 2024) https://www.socialdemocrats.ie/cairns-hails-impressive-local-election-results-for-soc-dems/

[5] Elections 2024, RTE https://www.rte.ie/news/elections-2024/results/#/local/national

[6] “It is “inevitable” that the Labour Party and Social Democrats will merge, Pat Rabbitte has predicted.” Newstalk (9 June 2024) https://www.newstalk.com/news/elections-2024-inevitable-that-labour-and-soc-dems-will-merge-pat-rabbitte-1733053

[7] Christina Finn, “Pressure on coalition to cut and run with early election, but leaders say they’re going all the way”, The Journal (10 June 2024) https://www.thejournal.ie/early-general-election-micheal-martin-6404574-Jun2024/

The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and not necessarily the views of FTI Consulting, its management, its subsidiaries, its affiliates, or its other professionals.

©2024 FTI Consulting, Inc. All rights reserved. www.fticonsulting.com

Related Articles

Predictions for Cybersecurity in 2024: Communications and Reputational Perspectives

March 7, 2024—What will the cybersecurity space look like in 2024? And what do companies need to do to ensure they are prepared from a...

Cybersecurity in Latin America: Cyber Threats Evolve in a Landscape of Incipient Resilience

January 25, 2024—Organizations in Latin America should not wait for regulators to impose cybersecurity readiness requirements, as prepara...

A Year of Elections in Latin America: Navigating Political Cycles, Seizing Long-term Opportunity

January 23, 2024—Around 4.2 billion people will go to the polls in 2024, in what many are calling the biggest electoral year in history.[...

FTI Consulting Appoints Oliver Williams as Head of its Strategic Communications Segment in the Middle East

July 2, 2024—Dubai, 2 July 2024 — FTI Consulting, Inc. (NYSE: FCN) today announced that Oliver Williams has been appointed as Head ...

FTI Consulting News Bytes – 28 June 2024

June 28, 2024—FTI Consulting News Bytes The world’s biggest record labels are suing two AI startups in a bid to protect their intell...

Global Public Affairs Newswire – 28 June 2024

June 28, 2024—Welcome to the latest installment of FTI Consulting’s fortnightly Global Public Affairs Newswire. This week, we br...